Skip to main content

Quevedo & Ponce

Quevedo & Ponce - Legal News

Can property lent under a commodatum agreement be acquired by prescription?

A commodatum is a contract commonly used in family, business, or trust-based relationships. It refers to the free loan of property for use, with the obligation to return it once the agreed time or purpose has been fulfilled.

The Ecuadorian Civil Code defines commodatum it’s Article 2077 as a contract through grants a non-fungible item to another for use it and later returned. This obligation to return the property is essential to understand why a good delivered under commodatum cannot be acquired through prescription.

For acquisitive prescription to apply, the law requires possession. Article 715 of the Civil Code states that possession means holding a thing with the intention of acting as its owner.

In a commodatum agreement, the borrower clearly recognizes that the property belongs to someone else and that the use is temporary. For this reason, the borrower is considered a mere holder, not a possessor.

Acquisitive prescription, regulated in Article 2392 of the Civil Code, allows a person to acquire ownership of property after possessing it for a certain period of time under specific conditions. However, because commodatum only creates holding and not possession, the borrower cannot acquire the property through prescription.

A commodatum agreement does not create possession that can lead to prescription. This situation would only change if there is an interversion of title, meaning that the holder begins to act as the owner and denies the rights of the real owner. This change must be clear and proven.

As long as the commodatum relationship continues and the borrower recognizes the owner’s rights, the passage of time will not allow the borrower to acquire the property through prescription.

Más Artículos

Actualización Laboral

Actualización Laboral

Actualización Laboral: Leyes y Directrices para Empresas en Ecuador. Descarga el archivo y obtén más detalles»

Ley Fintech. Esferas de regulación y contenido

Ley Fintech. Esferas de regulación y contenido

La Ley Fintech en Ecuador: Regulación de Servicios Financieros Tecnológicos y su Impacto en los Negocios Digitales.

Sentencia No. 639-19-JP/20 y acumulados

Sentencia No. 639-19-JP/20 y acumulados

La Corte Constitucional protege los derechos de migrar y la libertad de movimiento, exigiendo protocolos y medidas de reparación.

Reducción progresiva de la tarifa del impuesto a la salida de divisas

Reducción progresiva de la tarifa del impuesto a la salida de divisas

Reducción gradual del Impuesto a la Salida de Divisas (ISD) en Ecuador: Nuevas tarifas y fechas clave para el 2022.

Deducibilidad de las provisiones para atender el pago de pensiones jubilares patronales

Deducibilidad de las provisiones para atender el pago de pensiones jubilares patronales

Deducibilidad de Provisión de Jubilación Patronal: Reglas clave para el Impuesto a la Renta 2021 según resolución del SRI

1 … 38 39 40 41 42 … 45